Four glasses of ivory hen's milk, with small points of vanilla and without chantilly.
Four glasses of ivory hen's milk, with small points of vanilla and without chantilly.

THE FESTIVAL CARNET

Cooked Vanilla Christmas Eggnog

A recipe by CakeChristmas / Updated on 30 October 2026.

An alcohol-free homemade eggnog, prepared with a cooked and cooled egg base, then flavored with nutmeg.

15 minPREPARATION
10 minBAKING
2 hREST / CHILL

4 glasses of about 180 ml · Estimated total : 2 h 25

Kitchen Mode and Timer

Keep the recipe at hand during preparation.

Enables JavaScript to use the kitchen tools.

10:00

Choose a duration, then launch the timer.

Visual Timer: Keeps this page open. It does not sound an alarm. The cooking remains to be monitored.

eggnog is a creamy drink with eggs, milk and cream. Here, cook the whole base before cooling it: the eggs are not added raw in the glasses. A thermometer makes this step much more reliable than the observation of foam.

The recipe does not contain rum or brandy. Vanilla and a small pinch of nutmeg are enough for the party scent. The result should remain to drink, more fluid than a dessert cream; serve four small portions very cool after at least two hours of refrigeration.

That's all you need!

Equip me with a pack.

If you miss something, choose your ingredients from Monoprix and your utensils on Amazon. Adjust the quantities to your guests, then uncheck what you already have.

Choose the number of guests and uncheck what you already have at home.

Original quantity: 4 glasses of 180 ml approximately.

01 / The ingredients
Buy my ingredients

Only the ingredients checked. References and research at Monoprix.

02 / Utensils

Buttons open Amazon.fr in a new tab. An identified reference leads to its file; “Choose on Amazon” looks for the format of the recipe. Some utensils are sold in batches: groups the same references before ordering.

Original formats retained. Adapts containers or prepares several batches. Alternatives remain to be chosen.

Buy my utensils

Your selection contains only the checked items. Check products and availability at Monoprix for ingredients, on Amazon for utensils.

Amazon Affiliate Links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Your choices are memorized on this device.

The preparation step by step

  1. Prepare for cooling

    Fill a large bowl with cold water and ice cubes. Place a clean pitcher and a strainer next to it: the base will have to be cooled as soon as it is cooked.

  2. Separate the eggs

    Break each egg in a cup and separate the yolk and the white. Gather the four yolks in a bowl. Reserve the whites in the refrigerator for another cooked recipe.

  3. Mixing the sugar

    Pour the 50 g of sugar on the yolks. Whisk immediately one minute: the mixture should become more homogeneous and slightly lighter, without trying to form a very firm foam.

  4. Prepare the vanilla

    Split the half vanilla pod along its length. Scratches its seeds with the back of the knife. Put seeds and pod in the pan with 500 ml of milk and 150 ml of cream.

  5. Heat up dairy products

    Heat over medium heat until the mixture smokes slightly, without boiling. Stir the bottom with a spatula to prevent a skin from forming and attaching.

  6. Loosen the egg yolks

    Remove the pod. Gradually pour about a third of the warm milk over the sweetened yolks, constantly whipping. Then pour this mixture back into the saucepan with the remaining milk.

  7. Cuis while stirring

    Heat on low heat and stirs continuously by drawing eight, scraping the bottom and angles. Measure the temperature at the heart of the liquid, without pressing the probe on the metal.

  8. Reach the cooking mark

    Bring the base to 75 °C, then immediately remove it from the heat. Do not boil it: the yellows could form lumps. The base slightly covers the spatula but remains liquid.

  9. Filter and Cooled

    Pour through the strainer into the pitcher. Add the pinch of nutmeg, stir, and then put the pitcher in the ice bath. Stir regularly until the drink is cold, then cover and refrigerate for two hours.

  10. Stir before the service

    Stir the cold eggnog with a spoon. Divided into four small glasses. Serve without adding raw egg, raw foam or cream that would have remained at room temperature for a long time.

Conservation. Store covered in the refrigerator at 4°C or less and consumes within 24 hours. Keep the drink cold until service.

Recipe proposal with quantities and step by step. Times vary depending on the material: follow also the markers of texture and cooking.

The benchmarks for success

Avoid the lumps

A gentle heat and continuous brewing is better than a strong fire. The thermometer measures the liquid, not the bottom of the pan.

The nutmeg

A pinch is enough. A large amount would mask the vanilla and is not necessary to obtain the desired scent.

Questions Before You Start

Should we add alcohol?

Nope. This formula is an alcohol-free eggnog. Alcohol is never a substitute for cooking the egg base.

Can I use pasteurized eggs?

Yes, by keeping the same quantities and following their preservation. The cooking of this recipe remains the same.

Why does my eggnog thicken in the refrigerator?

The yellows and cream give body. Stir gently before serving; do not beat it for long to the point of turning it into foam.

Baking tips for this recipe

Substitutions and variations

To replace a main ingredient, choose another sheet designed with the one you want to use. Changing the proportions of fat, sugar or liquid can change the hold of the dessert.

More treats for your Christmas table

Recipes that share ingredients or the same preparation family.